Becoming a U.S. citizen is a goal that many immigrants work hard to achieve. However, past legal troubles can complicate the process. If you have a criminal history, even if it's from years ago, it’s natural to worry about how it might affect your application for naturalization. Before filing any paperwork, a U.S. citizenship lawyer consultation can help you understand how your specific case might be evaluated under immigration law.
How Criminal History Affects Your Application
The United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) takes criminal history seriously when reviewing applications. Citizenship is not just a benefit—it’s a legal status that comes with responsibilities and expectations. USCIS examines whether an applicant meets the “good moral character” requirement, which is often where criminal records become a problem.
Some convictions may lead to automatic denial, while others may not have as serious an effect. Each case depends on the details of the offense, the time that has passed, and whether rehabilitation has occurred. USCIS will look at your entire record, not just the last five years.
Crimes That Can Disqualify You from Naturalization
Certain crimes are considered so serious that they make an applicant permanently ineligible for citizenship. These are often referred to as “aggravated felonies” under immigration law, and they are different from what a state may consider a felony.
Here are examples of offenses that may permanently bar someone from becoming a U.S. citizen:
- Murder or attempted murder
- Sexual abuse of a minor
- Drug trafficking or drug-related crimes with a sentence of over five years
- Firearms offenses
- Fraud involving a loss of $10,000 or more
- Crimes of violence with a sentence of one year or more
In addition to these, crimes involving moral turpitude—such as theft, domestic violence, or assault—can also affect eligibility, especially if committed within five years of obtaining lawful permanent residency.
How USCIS Evaluates Good Moral Character
USCIS doesn’t just look at your record to check for disqualifying crimes. Officers also examine your behavior over the last five years to see if you demonstrate “good moral character.” This evaluation includes more than criminal offenses—it can involve things like unpaid taxes, failure to support dependents, or lying to obtain immigration benefits.
Even if you’ve never been arrested, USCIS can still deny your application if they believe you haven’t lived up to the standards required for citizenship. They expect honesty, responsibility, and community respect from every applicant.
Options If You Have a Criminal Record
A criminal record doesn’t always mean the end of your citizenship journey. In many cases, people can still qualify for naturalization if they show enough time has passed, demonstrate rehabilitation, or have convictions that don’t fall under automatic bars.
Some applicants may qualify for a waiver, while others can wait until their criminal issue no longer affects their eligibility. Timing, legal strategy, and detailed preparation of your case all matter. In more complex situations, post-conviction relief might help reduce the immigration consequences of past charges.
The key is not to guess or assume the worst. Every case is different, and a past mistake doesn’t always lead to a permanent obstacle.
Why Legal Guidance Makes a Big Difference
Working with an experienced immigration attorney can significantly improve your chances of success. A lawyer can assess your record, explain what USCIS is likely to focus on, and help you prepare the strongest application possible. If there are any risks of denial or removal, they can also help you consider safer options before proceeding.
Legal guidance is especially important if your criminal history includes multiple charges, any time served in jail, or offenses involving violence or fraud. An attorney can help gather character references, show evidence of rehabilitation, and craft a strong narrative for your application.
Trying to handle complex immigration matters alone often leads to mistakes, delays, or worse—deportation proceedings. It’s far better to invest time in fully understanding your legal position before submitting your naturalization forms.
Talk to a Citizenship Attorney Today
If you have questions about how your criminal history could affect your path to becoming a U.S. citizen, don’t wait. Speak with a qualified immigration attorney who can guide you toward the best path forward. A single consultation could clarify your eligibility, protect your legal status, and help you make informed choices. Getting the right legal support now may be the step that secures your future.
This post is provided by a third party who may receive compensation from the products or services they mention.
